The Secret to Higher Stock Market Returns
- It can be hard to know when exactly is the right time to buy into a stock.
- But as Alexander Green explains today, there’s a telltale sign – and reliable investment strategy – that rarely fails.
We’ve all seen it before…
A company announces an earnings miss… a product recall… a reduced profit outlook… and its shares plummet.
Should you step up and buy? The best answer is not immediately.
It takes big financial institutions – banks, mutual funds, endowments, pensions, etc. – weeks to accumulate a position… and weeks to unwind one.
So bad news is often followed by weeks of institutional selling that puts pressure on the stock and makes it prudent to wait before buying the stock if – indeed – you should buy it at all.
However, there is one glaring exception to this rule: when the insiders load up on the stock themselves.
Corporate executives and board members have an unfair advantage when they trade their own companies’ shares.
They have access to all sorts of material, nonpublic information about the future prospects of the business.
That’s why the federal government requires insiders to file a so-called Form 4 with the SEC, detailing how many shares they bought on what date and at what price.
So while you cannot know what the insiders know, you can at least know what they’re doing.
This is valuable intelligence indeed.
Let’s use JPMorgan Chase (NYSE: JPM) CEO Jamie Dimon as an example.
Over the past decade, he has been a sporadic buyer of his company’s stock. And his timing has been extraordinary.
At each point, he stepped up to buy when the market was punishing the shares.
For example, he bought a half-million shares in January 2009, when the financial crisis was in full swing and bank stocks were getting brutalized.
His timing wasn’t perfect. (It would be two more months before the market hit rock bottom.) But it was darn good, with shares bought as low as $22.93.
In July 2012, he bought another half-million shares, right after the stock got hammered by the London Whale trading debacle that resulted in a $6 billion loss at the bank.
And he purchased another half-million shares in January 2016 after markets tumbled on an oil price meltdown and fears that China’s economy was coming in for a hard landing.
In all, he spent $55 million to buy shares between $22.93 and $53.18.
Even after the dramatic sell-off in bank stocks this year, JPMorgan is substantially higher.
Dimon has not purchased shares of the bank lately. (He’s been recovering from heart surgery.) But plenty of other insiders at other companies have been loading up.
Think back to the second half of March when the market was in a full-blown meltdown.
Pundits argued back and forth about how much further the market might fall.
But corporate insiders did something entirely different. They used the market crash to make seven-figure purchases of their own companies’ shares.
In the days just before and after the March 23 bottom, for instance, Hadi Partovi – a director at Axon Enterprise (Nasdaq: AAXN) – paid $55.47 a share. As I write, it is 51% higher.
Stuart Grant, an insider at Eyenovia (Nasdaq: EYEN), purchased over 900,000 shares at $2.06. As I write, the stock is 81% higher.
Amerco (Nasdaq: UHAL) officer Edward Shoen purchased 9,600 shares at $225.41. As I write, the stock is 51 points higher.
Insider Clifford Sosin purchased more than 200,000 shares of Cardlytics (Nasdaq: CDLX) for as little as $30.90. As I write, it is 83% higher.
Directors David Goeddel and Peter Svennilson each bought over 170,000 shares of NGM Biopharmaceuticals (Nasdaq: NGM) at $11.63. As I write, it is 94% higher.
And Michael Calbert, an AutoZone (NYSE: AZO) director, bought over a million dollars of the stock at $870. As I write, it is more than 150 points higher.
Do you see a pattern here?
Don’t get me wrong. No investor bats a thousand, regardless of his or her investment approach.
Growth stocks sometimes fail to grow. Value stocks can become – ahem – even better values. And so-called Dividend Aristocrats sometimes cut their dividends and see their share prices plunge.
But when the officers and directors who run a company buy millions of dollars’ worth of their own companies’ stock with their own money at current market prices, it doesn’t get much better than that.
If you’re looking to improve your investment returns, ride the coattails of knowledgeable insiders.
It’s the best – and safest – way to gain a reliable edge.
About Alexander Green
An expert on momentum investing, value investing and investing based on insider activity, Alex worked as an investment advisor, research analyst and portfolio manager on Wall Street for 16 years. He now runs the wildly successful Oxford Communiqué, ranked as one of the top investment newsletters by Hulbert Digest for more than a decade. He is also the author of four national best-sellers: The Gone Fishin’ Portfolio, The Secret of Shelter Island, Beyond Wealth and An Embarrassment of Riches. He shares his wisdom in his free daily e-letter, Liberty Through Wealth.